The concept of medical altruism, which is central to health care delivery and both patient and physician well-being, is extraordinarily complex. Filled with nuance and interconnected layers, even its definition is problematic. Usually understood as a dynamic, context-dependent virtue, medical altruism can be viewed as a commitment by medical providers (physicians, nurses, and other providers) to use their power, position, privilege, and knowledge in the best interests of others (their patients) even at personal cost and varying degrees of effacement of self-interest. Seen in this light, medical altruism includes in its essence altruism (“other-regarding,” as coined by nineteenth-century French philosopher August Comte), and the morally obligatory trait of altruistic beneficence (as described by American ethicists Edmund Pellegrino and David Thomasma), which goes beyond the principles of benevolence (wishing others well) and nonmaleficence (not doing others harm).  

Regardless of whether medical altruism is approached from a philosophical, psychological, theological, evolutionary, professional, or cultural perspective, it must be distinguished from the concept of altruism in medicine. While medical altruism is individual and profession-centered, altruism in medicine is viewed as a commitment of the health care collective, including its professional organizations, institutions, economics, sociocultural environment, populations, and political systems to address healthcare based on altruistic rather than egoistic or self-centered values. Altruism in medicine, therefore, might also apply to selfless patient-originated decisions to donate blood, stem cells, organs, and other tissues, as well as healthcare provider-originated decisions to volunteer for humanitarian activities, combat global inequities, or share knowledge, time, and experience in degrees that are above and beyond what is expected of their professional duties and, in the case of physicians, their social contract with society. 

Further complicating discussions of medical altruism and altruism in medicine is the rapidly changing face of medical practice and health care environments. There are obvious tensions regarding the value and sustainability of selfless motivation, just as there are significant vulnerabilities and systemic weaknesses of existing health care institution-based frameworks and societal policies regarding professionalism and what constitutes ethical medical practice in a technology-driven, soon to be AI-dominated twenty-first century. These and other elements relating to altruism will be the focus of several future reflections on Colt’s Corner. Please subscribe and share.

• Pellegrino, ED and Thomasma DC. The virtues of medical practice. Oxford University Press, 1993.
• Creuss SR and Creuss RL. Professionalism and Medicine’s social contract with society. Virtual Mentor 2004;6(4):185-188.